Reply To: Desarda vs Grischkan’s two-layer Shouldice, etc…

Hernia Discussion Forums Hernia Discussion Desarda vs Grischkan’s two-layer Shouldice, etc… Reply To: Desarda vs Grischkan’s two-layer Shouldice, etc…

#19672
Tino_7
Participant
quote joep:

Hi Ddot14, according to HerniaSurge, as per the evidence published so far, Shouldice technique is the best non-mesh repair. They concluded that Desarda repair, at this point, simply do not have required data regarding its outcome, and shied away from recommending it.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10029-017-1668-x

I asked Dr Grischkan about the Desarda method and his response was that it has not been around long enough to demonstrate long-term success. He did not appear impressed with it. I do know someone who did great after seeing Dr Tomas in Ft Meyers – he was up and walking that same afternoon with hardly any discomfort.

New Report

Close

Skip to toolbar