Dr. Towfigh do you still stand by this statement?

Hernia Discussion Forums Hernia Discussion Dr. Towfigh do you still stand by this statement?

Viewing 3 reply threads
  • Author
    • #35825

      Because all the big tissue guys are now saying they have less than 1 percent recurrance rates. If you do, do you have any data on the real data? I spoke to Tomas by phone and of course he said his recurrance rate was under 1 percent. I asked if I could seen his records demonstrating this. The question took him by surprise and he of course refused saying he wasnt going to sit on the phone and argue with me. This is the dilemma that we patients face. We can’t get honest information so how are we expected to make a decision? I saw a post here where Dr. Todd Harris claimed a 20 percent tissue failure rate. So what is the answer?

      That said, in general, long term outcomes are best with mesh repair, when looking at hernia recurrence rates. They are typically (much) lower with the mesh repair. Anyone who claims a less than 1% hernia recurrence rate with non-mesh repair should be queried as to their data, whether it is published in a peer reviewed manner, length of followup, how recurrence was determined, etc. It is very difficult to get recurrence rates that low with tissue repair, as it relies on the integrity of the Patient’s tissues, and anyone who has a hernia, by definition, has some tissue impairment. For example, studies show lower amount of mature collagen in Patient’s with hernias. This, sewing abnormal tissue to itself is more likely to fail than if new tissue/mesh is brought in to support the repair.

    • #35834
      Good intentions

      Joe, you didn’t state the statement that Dr. Towfigh is being asked to support/stand by.

    • #35835

      Yes I did. The statement about mesh recurrance being low. And tissue 1 percent recurrance being dubious.

    • #35836

      If a question, it’s incoherent. You ought to restate it but put it in question form right from the start.

Viewing 3 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

New Report


Skip to toolbar