I offer open, lap, robotic. As a hernia specialist it is important to know as many techniques as possible so that you can tailor to the needs of the patient.
If mesh removal in the groin is necessary AND putting in mesh is relatively contraindicated OR the patient does not want another mesh repair AND a tissue repair is feasible, then it depends on the tissues, type of hernia, size of hernia which type of tissue repair I choose. There is no one size fits all. But I mostly repair normal size hernias with the Shouldice repair in these circumstances. But as I mentioned, all options are there and I may choose Marcy, Bassini, or Nyhus or McVay repair if other circumstances