Primary first-time hernias may be successfully repaired without mesh. I offer a robotic option for this as well.
Once the tissue has been affected with prior operations, then the results from non-mesh repair are dismal. More than half will fail, and then you are left with a more complex hernia to re-repair.
There are new hybrid mesh that may be a good compromise in a patient such as yourself. For example, TelaBio has a new product, Ovitex, which has minimal amount of polypropylene in it. The rest is a high quality biologic tissue with low inflammatory potential.